Chapter 5 — Shadows of Doubt

╔─── ¤ ◎ ¤ ───╗

Chapter 5
Shadows of Doubt

╚─── ¤ ◎ ¤ ───╝

♣

Longtail walked with a firm step through the undergrowth of the clearing, a mouse hanging from his jaw. The hunt had been good that morning, at least for him. The sun was beginning to filter through the branches, and although the air was still heavy with humidity, it promised a clearer day than the previous ones.

Upon reaching the entrance to the veterans’ den, he dropped the prey with a slight snort. Halftail lifted his head from his moss bed, blinking gratefully before closing his eyes again. Patchpelt, on the other hand, was already complaining from the shadows.

“Only one? Do you think we share half a jaw or what?”

“I know,” Longtail growled, not bothering to turn his head. “I’ll bring you another.”

But his attention was diverted when he saw a white and orange figure curled up against Halftail’s flank.

Lostface.

The young warrior was removing fleas with her teeth, with the delicacy of someone who was not in a hurry. Her good eye was half-closed, focused. Her breathing was steady. Beside her, Halftail purred very softly, barely a murmur of contentment.

Longtail tilted his head, watching her with some discomfort.

“What are you doing?” he asked.

She looked up, her only visible eye meeting his.

“I’m helping the veterans,” she replied softly. “The apprentices are exhausted. I thought I could do something useful.”

Longtail raised an eyebrow.

“It’s not your job.”

“I know,” she whispered. “But… I want to do it.”

Longtail did not respond immediately. He had known her for many moons, but lately her attitude had become different. Quieter. More docile. There were times when he noticed her withdrawn, even among the other warriors.

And it was not hard to understand why.

The pack.

The attack.

The memory was still fresh in the Clan, like a poorly healed wound. Her face said it all, even when she did not speak: the left side destroyed, the lost eye, the fur still growing in irregular patches.

But what hurt the most was how she had shrunk within herself.

Longtail looked towards the entrance of the medicine cats’ den.

Cloudtail was coming out of there, his tail waving lightly, his eyes fixed on the ground with a thoughtful expression. He was not looking at anyone. He was simply walking away, as if he had come from a place where he did not quite belong.

Lostface saw him too.

She stood still.

Her ears slowly lowered, and her muzzle returned to Halftail’s fur, but her movements lost their rhythm. Her paws were tense. Her breathing, more shallow.

Longtail clicked his tongue.

“If you have something to say to him… say it,” he growled in a low but direct voice. “No one here is going to guess what you’re thinking, Lostface. Sometimes you seem like a shadow.”

She did not respond.

She just lowered her head more, as if his words had slid down a slope too steep to catch them.

Patchpelt snorted from his corner.

“And the other prey?”

“I know!” Longtail snapped, turning impatiently. Then, more softly, he turned back to Lostface. “When you’re done, go eat something. You look thin.”

She looked at him for a moment. Then she nodded without a word.

Longtail turned and walked away, his fur shaking with each step. It wasn’t that he cared more than necessary. But there was something in that look, in that silence that clung to her like a spiderweb on dry leaves, that provoked a growl in his throat.

He couldn’t do much.

But he could say what others didn’t say.

Even if it wasn’t enough.

On the other hand, Longtail descended the slope with a determined step, his tail raised but loose, reflecting more irritation than alertness. The afternoon wind blew gently over the clearing, rustling the tops of the trees that protected the camp. His thoughts were a whirlwind of annoyance and distrust, and each stride that brought him closer to the medicine cats’ den only made him more aware of it.

“Cinderpelt has been too quiet lately. Fireheart too. As if everyone had swallowed their tongues since that she-cat appeared.”

He hadn’t seen either of them in almost half a day. Too many coincidences. Too much silence for his liking.

“And all since that RiverClan warrior was dragged here.”

Longtail gritted his teeth.

If it were up to him, he would have sent her back to the border as soon as she regained consciousness. They had enough of their own problems without having to care for an injured enemy, and worse: letting her sleep under the same roof as their leader. That made no sense.

“Since when has ThunderClan become so… soft?”

He stopped in front of the entrance to the medicine cats’ den. The smell of herbs was strong, dense, as if trying to cover something up. He blinked a couple of times before peeking in, his ears perked up.

The light inside was dim, and the silence even thicker than the outside air.

Bluestar was sleeping in the left corner, wrapped in a bed of fresh moss. Beside her, Mistyfoot was also resting, though less deeply. Longtail could see how the gray warrior’s ears twitched slightly as she noticed his presence.

He thought about saying something to her.

Nothing hostile. Just a question. An observation. Something that would confirm what everyone was starting to murmur.

But as soon as he took a step inside, Bluestar sat up.

Quick. Alert. Like a warrior on full watch.

She placed herself between him and Mistyfoot without saying a word.

She just looked at him.

Longtail stopped.

He snorted.

“Whatever…” he growled, turning his head to the side. “I wasn’t going to do anything, relax.”

His voice was not submissive, but neither did it directly challenge. It wasn’t worth it. Not when Bluestar’s eyes reminded him that the leader he knew, the one from before, could still roar if she wanted to.

He backed away without another word and left the cave. Not running. Not fleeing. But making it clear that he did not want to continue the conversation.

Still, as he walked away, he felt the weight of Bluestar’s gaze on his back.

Out of the corner of his eye, he saw her watching him.

Fixed. Silent.

Too protective for his liking.

“What’s all the fuss about that she-cat?”

She’s from another Clan. They’re supposed to be enemies, aren’t they?

The warrior code was clear. Loyalty should come above all. Above the past. Above feelings.

And yet, Bluestar guarded Mistyfoot as if she were more than a guest.

If she was hiding something…

Sooner or later, it was going to explode.

***

The brambles tangled in Fireheart’s paws as he took another step back among the thick bushes of the riverbank. The damp earth beneath his paws absorbed all sound, but every slight crack of a dry branch seemed like thunder at that moment.

“Get further in,” he whispered softly, turning slightly towards Cinderpelt.

The medicine cat, with her muzzle wrinkled in discomfort, obeyed without replying. She slipped between the ferns beside him, her tail brushing his side. They were almost shoulder to shoulder, hidden by the dense branches of a thorny bush, near a bend in the river where the vegetation was thickest.

On the other side of the clearing, the sounds of a patrol began to multiply.

Paws splashing against the shore. Muffled laughter. Paws moving quickly among the slippery stones of the edge. And then, words. Familiar voices.

Fireheart closed his eyes for a moment and held his breath.

A RiverClan patrol had decided to hunt right there.

“How lucky that the water is low today,” one of them murmured. “The fish are getting trapped in the branches.”

“Yes… but I don’t like coming this far. You know what happened,” replied another voice, this time more serious.

Cinderpelt tensed beside him, and Fireheart slightly turned his ear toward the sound.

“Because of Mistyfoot?” said a third.

The first one snorted.

“Not just that. Also because of how Leopardstar is reacting. She almost can’t stop talking about it. If Mistyfoot doesn’t appear soon, she’s going to start blaming seriously.”

There was a tense silence, interrupted only by the hum of the river.

“Do you think she might have crossed into another Clan?”

“And what other option is there? The river didn’t swallow her.”

“Stonefur hasn’t slept well since he saw her running into the forest. I noticed yesterday. He barely spoke.”

Fireheart frowned. So Stonefur had seen her. That confirmed that RiverClan already suspected that Mistyfoot was not just missing, but somewhere… specific.

“I wouldn’t be surprised if she’s in ThunderClan,” added a lower voice, as if not wanting to say it out loud.

“ThunderClan?! And why would they be hiding a foreign warrior?”

“I don’t know. But Bluestar has always been strange. And lately, she’s even crazier.”

Fireheart dug his claws into the ground, containing the urge to snort. Cinderpelt gave him a slight nudge to calm him down.

“If Mistyfoot is there… then ThunderClan is interfering,” continued the cat. “And that could mean war.”

“Don’t say that,” growled another. “Not without proof.”

“But we should watch their borders. Not just to see if Mistyfoot returns… but to see if any of them tries to contact us.”

The murmur faded again.

Fireheart and Cinderpelt remained still, not daring to move a muscle. Only the leaves swayed slightly with the wind, but in their bodies, every nerve seemed like a tense thread about to break.

Finally, the patrol began to move away, their voices gradually dissipating downstream. Fireheart slowly let out the air, although his heart was still beating strongly.

“That was closer than I like,” whispered Cinderpelt, her voice barely audible among the branches.

Fireheart nodded, still looking through the leaves.

“If they find out that Mistyfoot is with us…”

“It could all explode,” Cinderpelt finished for him.

Silence returned for a few seconds before Fireheart slowly turned his head toward his friend.

“We have to return to the camp. Bluestar must know that RiverClan already suspects. And Stonefur is starting to ask questions.”

“And Cloudtail…” murmured Cinderpelt, frowning.

Fireheart sighed.

“Yes. Him too.”

Cinderpelt began to get up carefully, shaking off the wet leaves that had stuck to her fur. Her lame paw tensed for a moment as she put weight on it, and the gesture of pain was as brief as it was disguised. But Fireheart noticed. He approached silently and offered his flank for her to lean on if she needed to.

“I’m fine,” she murmured, although she accepted his help to steady herself.

Fireheart took another look beyond the bush that had hidden them. The RiverClan patrol was already moving away, the murmur of their voices diminishing downstream. The air around them felt colder, as if the conversation they had just overheard had left a current of unease suspended in the branches.

“Let’s go,” he whispered. “If we move now, we can take the path between the reeds without—”

A meow, clear and masculine, stopped them in their tracks.

“What are you doing here?”

Both turned abruptly.

Stonefur emerged from the ferns, his dark silhouette outlined against the sun that was beginning to filter through the clouds. His ears were perked up and his tail was low, in a neutral attitude. There was no aggression in his posture, but no tranquility either.

Fireheart felt his stomach tense like a claw dug in from the inside.

Cinderpelt said nothing, although her bad paw trembled slightly.

Stonefur’s eyes moved from one to the other, and then to the bush where they had clearly been hiding. His whiskers moved slightly.

There was no smell of prey. They had no dirt on their claws. They weren’t hunting.

But they had been spying.

“Why are you here?” repeated the RiverClan warrior, this time less harshly.

Fireheart swallowed.

The idea of running crossed his mind for an instant. Cinderpelt seemed to think the same: her paws were tense, as if ready to turn and disappear among the trees. But they still didn’t move.

Because Stonefur… wasn’t being hostile.

He was hesitating.

He seemed more confused than furious.

More worried than threatening.

Fireheart returned his gaze. A second of silence. And then, with a long breath, he nodded slightly. He turned slightly toward Cinderpelt. Their eyes met. They didn’t need words. The same thought was clear in both:

We can’t lie. But we can’t tell everything.

Fireheart felt the weight of that idea like a stone hanging from his tongue. His fur was still bristling from the tension of the unexpected encounter, his heart galloping under his ribs.

Stonefur was in front of them, his gaze interrupted by worry, not hostility. Still, Fireheart knew that one wrong word could ignite something no one wanted.

“We are here…,” began Fireheart, his paws anchored to the ground, his voice barely steady. “Because… because…”

Say it.

Because Mistyfoot is with us.

Because your sister could die if Leopardstar finds out.

Because Bluestar protects her as if…

But before those words escaped, a voice rose beside him.

“We came to look for some herbs,” interrupted Cinderpelt, her tone calm, measured.

Stonefur blinked, bewildered.

“Herbs?”

“Yes,” she affirmed. “There are certain plants that grow only near this shore. In an area where the river curves and leaves wet deposits. Normally we don’t cross borders, but we didn’t go too far in. Fireheart escorted me. It was going to be quick, but we heard the patrol and decided to hide to avoid problems.”

Fireheart glanced at her sideways.

She was protecting him. Protecting Mistyfoot.

It wasn’t a lie.

But it wasn’t the whole truth either.

Stonefur lowered his gaze for a moment. He seemed to process their words, not yet finding a reason to distrust, but not relaxing his back either.

“And did you see anything strange? Have you… have you seen Mistyfoot?”

Both swallowed.

Fireheart felt his muzzle dry. He was going to speak, to say something—anything—but Cinderpelt spoke up again, her voice still calm, almost compassionate.

“No,” she said. “We haven’t seen her.”

And although the tone was serene, there was something more in her words. A veiled sadness. As if it hurt to say it.

Fireheart looked away. He couldn’t speak. Not now. The words stuck in his throat. Because at that moment, he saw the contained anguish in Stonefur’s eyes.

The brother.

Not the warrior.

Stonefur took a step back, his gaze falling to the ground for a moment. He didn’t say anything right away. The silence stretched between them like a taut sheet in the wind.

Then he looked up, his eyes dimmer than before.

“I understand,” he said.

Cinderpelt inclined her head. Not in submission. But as someone who carries something they cannot share.

“If you see her,” added Stonefur. “If you hear anything… let me know. Please.”

Cinderpelt nodded.

“I will.”

Stonefur didn’t respond further. He turned around and slowly disappeared among the ferns. He didn’t run. He didn’t flee. He walked with a silent step, as if carrying a shadow attached to his fur.

Only when his footsteps completely faded away did Fireheart let out his breath.

Cinderpelt was still looking in the direction he had gone.

“I couldn’t tell him the truth,” she murmured.

“I know,” said Fireheart, his voice hoarse. “But it hurts. He… was more sad than upset.”

“Because he is,” she replied. “And if he knew she was just a few borders away… and he couldn’t see her… what do you think he would do?”

Fireheart didn’t answer.

He just lowered his head, feeling the mud weigh heavier on his paws.

Mistyfoot rested safely. But outside that den, the world was beginning to fracture.

Fireheart sighed, his breath escaping his muzzle in a heavy exhale as the trees of ThunderClan began to surround them again. Beside him, Cinderpelt walked with a steady pace, although the slight tilt of her body revealed the tension accumulated in her lame paw.

The silence between them lasted long, until the wet stones under their paws gave way to firmer, more familiar moss.

“It really affects him,” Fireheart finally said, his voice low.

Cinderpelt didn’t need to ask who he was referring to. Both knew that the image of Stonefur, standing with a look full of anguish and disappointment, wouldn’t easily fade from their minds.

“He’s her brother,” she replied, not taking her eyes off the path. “He has the right to be worried.”

“I know Bluestar did it to protect her,” murmured Fireheart. “But… I’m not sure she understands what this is causing.”

Cinderpelt stopped for a few seconds, her tail moving slightly in time with her thoughts.

“When Mistyfoot heals,” she said firmly, “we’ll send her back to her Clan. Whether Bluestar wants it… or not.”

Fireheart nodded seriously. It was the right thing to do. ThunderClan couldn’t keep a foreign warrior, not when peace between the Clans hung by a thread.

They resumed their march.

The forest felt more closed than before, as if it knew that the return brought no relief, only decisions no one wanted to make.

“And whatever happens,” added Cinderpelt, turning her muzzle towards him, “we won’t mention any of this to anyone. Not to Brackenfur. Not to Cloudtail.”

“Especially not to Cloudtail,” said Fireheart, with a barely audible growl.

Cinderpelt let out a snort.

“Speaking of him… you’d better take care of that rebellious ball of fur yourself.”

Fireheart looked at her sideways, knowing what was coming.

“And if I don’t?”

“Then I’ll have him defleaing veterans until he becomes one.”

Fireheart couldn’t help but let out a slight laugh, although his face returned to seriousness at once.

“I’ll do it,” he promised.

Cinderpelt stopped for a moment when they reached a narrow puddle. Fireheart crossed it first and waited on the other side. Seeing that a few drops of the river still fell from his friend’s whiskers, he leaned in and quickly licked her ear.

“It was just water,” she said, glaring at him, although her tone was more irritated than real.

She gave him a slight tap on the side with her paw, soft but direct.

“Go now. Find Cloudtail before he starts another scene in the warriors’ den.”

Fireheart nodded, straightening up.

“You go back to Mistyfoot,” he told her, not hiding his concern. “Make sure she doesn’t find out how close Stonefur was. Not yet.”

Cinderpelt nodded again and turned around, her tail raised as she disappeared among the bushes.

Fireheart stayed for a moment in the clearing, the sun filtering through the branches, caressing his back. There were many unsaid words. Many decisions that weren’t his… but somehow, he had to bear them.

And now, he had to find Cloudtail.

Because if there was one thing Fireheart knew, it was that borders could be broken with a bite… or with a look too long.

And Cloudtail had done both.

For her part, Cinderpelt walked at her own pace. The sound of Fireheart’s paws was already fading into the undergrowth, firm and determined as always. She, on the other hand, let the damp moss under her paws guide her steps, feeling every slight crunch of leaves, every variation in the terrain with the attention only a medicine cat could have.

She stopped for a moment, her gaze fixed on the curve of the path. Maybe she could gather something useful before returning. It wouldn’t be the first time that the moisture of the riverbank made rare plants sprout, even out of season.

She crouched among some reeds, sniffing for willow bark or some sorrel root that survived the mild climate. But a movement, quick and smooth, made her lift her head.

A figure among the bushes.

Her silhouette quickly hid, though not enough. Cinderpelt narrowed her eyes. The sun filtered through the leaves barely drew a clear outline, but she had seen enough to recognize the fur.

She moved in silence.

Her lame paw was no impediment when stealth was a matter of necessity. With the practice of moons, she had learned to adapt. She slid between the ferns, without breaking a single leaf, her body close to the ground.

And then she saw her.

Stopped, with her chest heaving, looking the other way as if she didn’t know what to do.

Lostface.

The young cat startled at the sight of her. She took a step back, her only visible half of her face twisting with surprise.

“Cinderpelt!” she murmured, her voice barely louder than a whisper.

Cinderpelt tilted her head.

“What are you doing here?”

Lostface swallowed, her body tense like a branch about to break.

“I… I got disoriented,” she replied quickly. “I came out to… get some air, and I think I went further than I thought. I was already returning. I swear.”

Cinderpelt looked at her intently. She didn’t say anything.

Lostface lowered her gaze.

“I’m going back now. Seriously,” she said before turning and running in the opposite direction, without waiting for another word.

The medicine cat stayed in her place, watching as the white and orange silhouette disappeared among the bushes. Her tail waved in the air before the silence enveloped her again.

Cinderpelt sighed.

We have to be more careful.

She couldn’t afford distractions. Not with Mistyfoot still in the den. Not with Cloudtail crossing boundaries. And especially not with eyes of the Clan spying from the shadows.

Bluestar’s daughter…

That truth still weighed on her shoulders like an invisible claw. She wasn’t just a wounded warrior. Not just a temporary outsider. Mistyfoot was the heart of a secret that could split ThunderClan in two.

And Bluestar…

Cinderpelt raised her eyes to the sky, where a gap between the leaves revealed a strip of blue light.

She remembered another figure, now distant in her memory: Silverstream.

The riverclan cat. Graystripe’s impossible love. The one who died under her paws, bleeding out, without her being able to do anything. The helplessness still burned in her bones as if it were yesterday.

She would have understood this. She would have smiled, even.

Silverstream never worried too much about the rules. Only about love. About the truth of her heart.

But this…

Cinderpelt clenched her jaws.

This was different.

This was her leader. The cat who was supposed to embody the code. The secret mother of an enemy warrior. The protector of something that shouldn’t even exist.

And yet, part of her understood.

Too much.

Her tail curled around her paws as she lowered her head, as if seeking to hide from her own thoughts.

Fireheart.

The image of his face appeared uncalled. That intense, yet warm gaze. His way of caring. Of looking after her. Of trusting her with everything without a doubt.

She shouldn’t think like this.

I mustn’t think like this.

He was a warrior. She, a medicine cat. There were paths that didn’t cross. And she had to accept that he would never see beyond his calling. He would never look at her the way she, in silence, wished he would.

And that… was fine.

Because her duty was greater.

And more painful.

She let out another sigh, long and frustrated.

“Romance is too complicated,” she murmured, not expecting anyone to hear her.

Neither the forest, nor the leaves, nor the wind responded.

But the weight in her chest remained.